Court Records Blog

Court Records Access

Court Records Blog header image 2

Nuisance Claims

January 9th, 2009 · 8 Comments

A nuisance isn’t just an annoying person, it is actual a legal concept, one which can be sued upon.  In legal terms, a nuisance occurs through the unlawful or unreasonable use of land that causes an injury, or interferes with rights of another person, or the public.  In the legal system, tenants and landowners actually possess a legal right to enjoy their property.  This right is known as the right of quiet enjoyment.  If an activity interferes with this right, this could constitute a legal nuisance.

A nuisance interferes in a person or a community’s enjoyment by causing damages, danger, inconvenience, or annoyance.  Thus, nuisances can be sights, sounds, or even smells.   For example, if your neighbor is constantly playing obnoxiously loud music throughout all hours of the day, or perhaps a business in your area creates foul smelling odors, these may be actionable legal nuisance claims.  Other examples of nuisance claims include barking docks, blocked views, blocked access, piled garbage, and abandoned cars.

A nuisance can be either a public nuisance or a private nuisance.  A private nuisance occurs only to a private citizen while a public nuisances affects a greater community.  So, in the example of loud music, if you live in an apartment building where the general apartment community is disturbed by the sound, this would be a public nuisance.  Whereas, if only on person were bothered by a neighbor’s noisy music, then the nuisance would likely be a private nuisance.  Generally though, a private nuisance includes the inference of a property right, while a public nuisance interferes with public health, peace, safety, and convenience.

Furthermore, there are two legal theories under which a nuisance could be tried under in court.  These two theories are nuisance in fact and nuisance per se.  In a nuisance in fact case, a jury will decide whether an activity is a nuisance by looking at all the surrounding circumstance.  In a nuisance per se case, there is no jury, and a judge will decide that the activity or structure is a nuisance just by virtue of its existence.  Essentially, it would be a nuisance no matter what the circumstances are.  Most nuisance cases are nuisance in fact.  If there is a nuisance claim, the plaintiff could be suing for a remedy of money damages and/or an injunction, which requires the activity to stop.

Nuisance cases are typically civil cases and therefore occur in a court with jurisdiction over general civil cases.  Depending on the court system of a state or county, you may find nuisance cases in small claims court, or specialized court divisions. Some counties even allow users to review nuisance case information online. Check with CourtReference.com to find out links to online records services and contact information for courts across the US.   Nuisance cases could be a great records resource for background checks!  Also, if you are the one affected by a nuisance, but are not looking to engage in a legal claim, there are circumstances where you can first file a general complaint with the appropriate officials.

clperkins82

Tags: Courtreference.com · Finding Court Records

8 responses so far ↓

  • 1 StevenG // Aug 13, 2009 at 12:19 pm

    Secondhand tobacco smoke is a nuisance. Smokers do not seem to or want to, claim responsibilty for the gaseous toxic emissions they are creating and poisoning everyone in the immediate vicinity with. I think that the courts would support claims of nuisance for exposure to secondhand tobacco smoke and provide financial damages as compensation for the physical and detrimental health effects one derives from breathing it in.

  • 2 J // Nov 28, 2009 at 11:00 pm

    One neighbor’s car stereo is so loud it vibrates my home whenever he drives by or sits in his driveway to listen to his music.
    Another neighbor has weekly parties where they are loud with their voices and with their music well past 10p.
    Buying a home was suppose to help rid ourselves of this kind of nuisance! After more than a year, it’s time to look into filing complaints rather than calling the police to quiet them. We’ve been patient enough.

  • 3 Gigi // Apr 28, 2010 at 8:54 am

    What are some of the most superfluous nuisance cases ever tried?

  • 4 Jon // Jun 23, 2010 at 7:23 am

    A commercial property owner owns a huge rock that keeeps getting dragged/bashed into the street by a busy 4-way intersection in Dallas. The rock damaged my car, and I want compensation. How do I obtain public records that help me establish prescedent? Neither the property manager nor the property insurance company want to pay…

  • 5 G McMillan // Oct 10, 2010 at 12:36 pm

    Where do you file a general complaint about private nuisance? Who are the appropriate officials?

  • 6 linda // Apr 30, 2012 at 9:51 am

    my neioghbor stock piles his household garbage. it smells bad, creates litter, and attracks rodents.

  • 7 Latonya Flowers // Oct 22, 2012 at 7:35 am

    I was assaulted by a neighbor on DEc. 2011 as a result I only obtained a protective order. Since then this person has intentionally had her kid attck my kid and has even gone as far as sitting on the porch where I reside, pretending to be visiting with my neighbors . It is a public housing community and I have complained to the property managers who refuse to do anything unless I am physically attacked. This has gone on for so long that it is now a nuisance, can I sue both the property manager and the annoying neighbor?

  • 8 kathy // Jun 15, 2013 at 3:51 pm

    my neighbors lets their boys ride dirt bikes on their pap paws yard which is right next to ours,we can not set on our porch or enjoy our property for the noise and dust.what can be done?

Leave a Comment